A Groundwork Collaborative report released on November 16, 2026 found that 29.1% of 351 products Amazon promoted as Black Friday and Cyber Monday deals in 2024 and 2025 were priced the same or higher than their lowest price in the previous 30 days, and 9.4% cost more. Amazon disputes the findings, saying the study cherry-picked about 350 items from more than 10 million deals.
Black Friday Fake Discount in US 2026 – Introduction
Black Friday fake discount in US 2026 come from a handful of price-tracking studies, and they disagree on how often a “deal” is a real markdown. The newest, from the economic policy group Groundwork Collaborative, found that nearly 1 in 3 promoted Amazon deals offered no savings over the month before the sale. Amazon says the study is unfair and that its deal badge only promises a price no higher than the recent low.
Shoppers are paying attention. Bain & Company reports that 70% of US consumers plan to use Black Friday and Cyber Monday promotions this year, up from 64% in 2025. This report covers the studies, the methods, Amazon’s response, other price-tracking research, state pricing rules and the lawsuits. It does not say any retailer broke the law. Black Friday is November 27, 2026.
Interesting Facts About Black Friday Discounts in US 2026
Share of Amazon "Deals" With No Savings, by Look-Back Window (1 block = 2%)
10 days before | ███████████▊ 23.5%
30 days before | ██████████████▌ 29.1%
90 days before | ████████████████████████████▋ 57.3%
| Fact | Data |
|---|---|
| Products analyzed (Groundwork) | 351 |
| Same or higher than the 30-day low | 29.1% |
| More expensive than the 30-day low | 9.4% |
| Same or higher than the 90-day low | 57.3% |
| Median overpayment on “worse” deals | 19% |
| Typical product at or below sale price | On 8 of the 30 days before |
| Amazon’s reply | 98% at or below prior 30-day price |
| Shoppers planning to use promotions (Bain) | 70% |
Source: Groundwork Collaborative, Deal or Decoy? Amazon’s Deceptive Discounts (November 16, 2026); Techlicious; Android Headlines; Bain & Company (October 13, 2026).
The table shows the central dispute. Groundwork compared each sale price with the lowest Keepa-recorded price in the 30 days before the event. It found 29.1% of deals were no cheaper and 9.4% were more expensive. Looking back 90 days, 57.3% were no cheaper. Amazon says that 98% of products were at or below their prior 30-day price.
Both can be true because they measure different things. Groundwork counts a deal as having “no savings” if the same price existed at any point in the prior month. Amazon says its badge only means the price is no higher than the recent low, so a deal that matches the low counts as legitimate. Readers should judge which standard matches what a “Black Friday Deal” label promises.
Amazon Black Friday Deals Study 2026: What Did Groundwork Find?
Groundwork Sample by Sale Event (products, 1 block = 10)
Black Friday 2025 | ████████████████ 160
Cyber Monday 2025 | ████████████▎ 123
Black Friday 2024 | ████▊ 48
Cyber Monday 2024 | ██ 20
| Measure | Figure |
|---|---|
| Products in the analysis | 351 |
| Black Friday 2025 | 160 |
| Cyber Monday 2025 | 123 |
| Black Friday 2024 | 48 |
| Cyber Monday 2024 | 20 |
| Window used for headline | 30 days |
| Data source | Keepa price histories |
Source: Groundwork Collaborative (November 16, 2026).
Groundwork looked at products on the curated deals pages that Amazon itself described as some of its best deals. It tracked 351 products across four events, using Keepa, a service that records Amazon prices several times a day. It compared each product’s lowest sale-event price with the lowest price in the 30 days before the event began.
The headline numbers hold across windows. 23.5% of deals were no cheaper than a price available in the 10 days before the event, 29.1% at 30 days and 57.3% at 90 days. Half of the no-savings items were at or below the sale price on at least 8 of the 30 days. The group says the share is not a flash effect. The median overpayment on deals that cost more was 19%.
Stress Tests on Amazon Deal Findings 2026: Do the Results Hold?
Share Same or Worse Under Different Tests (1 block = 2%)
Excluding one-day lows | ████████████▌ 25.1%
Crediting lightning deals | ████████████▌ about 25%
Excluding last 7 days | ██████████ about 20%
Amazon-own prices only | ██████████████████ 35.9%
| Stress Test | Share Same or Worse |
|---|---|
| Main result, 30-day window | 29.1% |
| Excluding one-off one-day price lows | 25.1% |
| Crediting lightning deal prices | About 1 in 4 |
| Excluding the 7 days before the sale | About 1 in 5 |
| Days 8 to 90 before the sale | 51.6% |
| Amazon-sold items only | 35.9% |
Source: Groundwork Collaborative, Appendix D (November 16, 2026).
Groundwork ran several stress tests. Excluding one-day price dips left 25.1% of deals no cheaper than the recent low. Crediting lightning deals, which usually last a few hours, left about 1 in 4. Dropping the final week before the sale, to account for early event deals, left about 1 in 5. Restricting the data to items sold by Amazon itself raised the share to 35.9%.
Amazon pushes back on the early-event point. It says some of the earlier lows were Early Event Deals that it ran just before the main sale. Groundwork says it could not identify those products systematically, so it removed the whole prior week as a generous test. Between 8 and 90 days before the sale, 51.6% of deals were still the same or worse.
Amazon’s Response to the Fake Discount Study 2026: What Does Amazon Say?
Two Views of the Same Deals
Groundwork: no savings vs 30-day low | ██████████████████ 29.1%
Amazon: at or below 30-day price | ██████████████████████████████████████ 98%
| Issue | Groundwork View | Amazon View |
|---|---|---|
| Sample size | 351 products | Cherry-picked from more than 10 million deals |
| What counts as a deal | Cheaper than any price in prior 30 days | Not higher than the lowest price in the past 30 days |
| Share at or below prior price | 29.1% same or higher | 98% at or below |
| Early lows | Tested by removing the last week | Some were Early Event Deals |
| Example, $129.95 item | A 12-day-old same price means no savings | Same price still counts as a legitimate deal |
Source: Groundwork Collaborative; Techlicious and Yahoo Shopping (November 2026); Android Headlines (November 2026).
Amazon calls the study unfair. It argues that about 350 items are a tiny slice of more than 10 million deals across the two events. Techlicious explains the difference: if a price dropped to $129.95 twelve days before Black Friday and stayed there, Amazon’s rule treats it as a legitimate deal, because it matches the month’s low, while Groundwork counts it as no savings.
The practical takeaway is the same from either side. A deal badge tells you the price is not higher than its recent low, not that it is the lowest of the year. Techlicious recommends checking price history before buying anything over $50, using Keepa or CamelCamelCamel. Both tools chart the same data for free, and CamelCamelCamel and Keepa cover the life of the product, not just one year.
Black Friday Price Examples 2026: Which Products Cost More Than Before?
Overpayment vs Recent Low, Examples (1 block = 5%)
UGG Butte boots | ████████████████▌ 83%
Hunter rain boots | ███████████▊ 59%
Carhartt beanie | ██████▊ 34%
Apple Watch Series 10 | ██▌ 13%
| Product | Sale Price | Earlier Price | Sale Cost vs Earlier Low |
|---|---|---|---|
| UGG Butte boots | $179.98 | $98.40, 27 days before | 83% more |
| Hunter short rain boots | $126.99 | $79.97, 9 days before | 59% more |
| Carhartt knit beanie | $19.77 | $14.74, 10 days before | 34% more |
| Apple Watch Series 10 | $679.99 | $602, nearly a month before | 13% more |
| Beats Solo 4 | $129.95 | $129.95, 12 days before | Same |
| Dyson handheld vacuum | $249.95 | $249.95, 17 days before | Same |
| Fitbit Charge 6 | $99.95 | $99.95, 20 days before | Same |
Source: Groundwork Collaborative, Findings (November 16, 2026).
Groundwork named specific products from the 2025 events. A UGG boot priced at $179.98 on Cyber Monday had been $98.40 twenty-seven days earlier. Hunter rain boots on sale for $126.99 had been $79.97 nine days before. An Apple Watch Series 10 listed at $679.99 on Black Friday had been $602 nearly a month earlier, a 13% premium.
Other items simply matched an earlier price. A Beats Solo 4 at $129.95, a Dyson vacuum at $249.95 and a Fitbit Charge 6 at $99.95 were each available at that price 12, 17 and 20 days before the sale. A Weber grill carried a 62% badge off a $64.99 list price at $24.99. These examples are selected, so they illustrate the pattern without measuring it.
Other Black Friday Price Tracking Studies 2026: What Do Different Researchers Find?
Studies Finding No Savings or Price Hikes (selected, 1 block = 5%)
Visualping Prime Day 2026, matched low | █████████ 44.7%
Visualping Prime Day 2026, higher | ████████▌ 42.8%
Dutch consumer group, no discount | ████████ over 40%
KnownHost 2024, price hikes | █████▉ 29%
| Study | Finding |
|---|---|
| Visualping, Prime Day June 2026 | 44.7% matched the 30-day low; 42.8% priced higher (1,000+ products) |
| Dutch Consumers’ Association, 2026 | More than 40% of 100+ air fryer and speaker “deals” had no discount |
| KnownHost, Black Friday 2024 | 29% of 65 tech products had price hikes before the sale, averaging 20.5% |
| KnownHost, same study | Only 42% of items had stable prices before a drop |
| British consumer group, 2024-2025 | None of 175 items at eight retailers was lowest on Black Friday |
| TechRadar study, 2024 | 37% of hot tech products had price hikes just before Black Friday |
Source: Groundwork Collaborative (endnotes); Benzinga; TechRadar; Yahoo Shopping citing The Guardian (November 2026).
Other researchers also find gaps between sale and recent prices, though methods differ. Visualping tracked more than 1,000 Amazon products on Prime Day in June 2026 and found 44.7% matched the lowest price of the previous month and 42.8% cost more. The Dutch Consumers’ Association found over 40% of 100+ products had no real discount.
Older Black Friday studies point the same way. KnownHost tracked 65 tech products in 2024 and found 29% had price hikes averaging 20.5% before the sale. A TechRadar-reported study found 37% of the hottest tech products saw significant price hikes before Black Friday 2024. The same study found Black Friday prices were the lowest in 72% of cases compared with two weeks earlier, and 85% compared with three months earlier. The results depend on how far back the researcher looks.
Which Categories Have the Most Misleading Black Friday Discounts 2026?
Category Patterns Reported
Price hikes before sale (KnownHost): accessories > headphones > smartwatches > laptops
Least likely to see hikes: TVs and tablets
Groundwork: toys and games had more than triple the share of "same or worse" deals vs beauty
| Category Finding | Source |
|---|---|
| Tech accessories most likely to see pre-sale price hikes | KnownHost (2024) |
| Headphones, smartwatches and laptops next | KnownHost (2024) |
| TVs and tablets least likely to see hikes | KnownHost (2024) |
| Toys and games: more than triple the beauty share of same-or-worse deals | Groundwork (2026) |
| Largest single hike in a week: Fire TV Stick, price doubled | KnownHost (2024) |
Source: KnownHost via Benzinga; Groundwork Collaborative, Appendix C (November 2026).
Category matters. KnownHost found tech accessories were most likely to see price hikes before Black Friday, followed by headphones, smartwatches and laptops. TVs and tablets were least likely, so they are where shoppers were most likely to find genuine savings. The largest weekly hike was Amazon’s Fire TV Stick, whose price doubled before the sale.
Groundwork reports a different category split. Among Amazon-promoted deals, the share of toys and games available at the same price or lower before the sale was more than triple the share for beauty products. The two studies cover different years, retailers and product sets, so do not combine them. Use category as a prompt to check price history, not as proof.
Black Friday 2026 Shopper Behavior: How Many Plan to Chase Deals?
Shoppers Planning to Use Black Friday and Cyber Monday Promotions (1 block = 2%)
2025 | ████████████████████████████████ 64%
2026 | ███████████████████████████████████ 70%
| Shopper Measure | Figure |
|---|---|
| Planning to use promotions, 2026 (Bain) | 70% |
| Planning to use promotions, 2025 | 64% |
| Black Friday to Cyber Monday sales forecast (Bain) | Above $85 billion |
| Weekend shoppers, 2025 (NRF) | 202.9 million |
| Cyber Monday online sales, 2025 (Adobe) | $14.25 billion |
| US personal saving rate, Sept 2026 | 3.8% (5.7% in Jan 2025) |
| Amazon share of US e-commerce | Nearly 40% |
Source: Bain & Company (October 13, 2026); NRF (December 2, 2025); Adobe (December 2025); Groundwork Collaborative citing the Bureau of Economic Analysis.
Deal-hunting is rising. Bain says 70% of consumers plan to use promotions this year, up from 64% in 2025, and it forecasts more than $85 billion in Black Friday through Cyber Monday sales. A record 202.9 million people shopped over the weekend in 2025. Groundwork notes that the US personal saving rate fell from 5.7% in January 2025 to 3.8% in September 2026.
That context is why price accuracy matters to shoppers. Amazon holds nearly 40% of US e-commerce and has about 200 million US Prime subscribers, according to Groundwork. If shoppers delay purchases to catch a sale, as many say they do, a deal that matches last month’s price costs them time without saving money. A genuine deal and an average price can look the same on the badge.
State Pricing Laws and Fake Discounts 2026: What Rules Apply?
Look-Back Rules in Selected Jurisdictions (days)
EU Omnibus Directive (lowest price) | ███████ 30
Oregon (good faith, generally) | ███████ 30
Connecticut (actual sale) | ██████████████████ 90
Utah (regular price) | ████ 15
| Jurisdiction | Rule Summary |
|---|---|
| Federal (FTC Guides) | Former price must be an actual, bona fide price for a reasonably substantial period |
| California | Former price must have prevailed within the 3 months before the ad |
| Connecticut | Sold at that price within 90 days or offered for 4 weeks |
| Massachusetts / New Jersey | Offered on 28 of the prior 90 days, or sales-based tests |
| Oregon | Former price used in good faith, generally within 30 days |
| Utah | Not a regular price if not offered in the 15 days before |
| European Union | Discounts must reference the lowest price in the prior 30 days |
Source: Groundwork Collaborative, Appendix B, State Laws on Discount Advertising (November 2026).
US rules focus on whether the “was” price is honest, not whether the sale price is the lowest recent price. Groundwork says the FTC’s guides do not define terms like “regular basis” and have not been actively enforced since the Nixon administration, a claim that is the group’s characterization. It lists specific discount rules in about 13 states, with others relying on general consumer protection laws.
Groundwork proposes that retailers disclose the lowest price in the previous 30 days next to any sale price, as the EU requires. The EU rule applies to sales to EU consumers, not to US sales. Retailers and some policymakers may disagree with the proposal, and no federal change has been announced. Shoppers who want that comparison today must check a price tracker themselves.
Amazon Discount Lawsuits and Rulings: What Legal Challenges Exist?
Pricing-Related Actions Cited by Groundwork
2014 | US class action over list prices
2017 | Canada Competition Bureau, $1.1 million
2018 | UK Advertising Standards Authority ruling
2025 | German court ruling; US Prime Day class action
| Year | Action | Outcome or Status |
|---|---|---|
| 2014 | Class action over list prices in California | Alleged deceptive list prices |
| 2017 | Canadian Competition Bureau | Amazon paid $1.1 million |
| 2018 | UK advertising regulator | Complaints upheld on inflated savings |
| July 2025 | German regional court | Ruled Prime Deal Days reference prices misleading |
| September 2025 | US Prime Day class action | Alleged 40% off on a tablet sold at $72.18 vs about $50 |
Source: Groundwork Collaborative, endnotes (November 16, 2026). These are allegations or rulings in separate cases.
Groundwork lists several earlier actions over Amazon’s reference prices. In 2017 Amazon paid $1.1 million to settle with the Canadian Competition Bureau. In 2018 the UK advertising regulator upheld complaints. In July 2025 a German court found Prime Deal Days reference prices misleading. A September 2025 US class action alleges a children’s tablet was shown 40% off but sold for $72.18, against about $50 months earlier.
Not every case concerns discounts. Amazon paid $2.5 billion in 2025 to settle an FTC case over Prime enrollment and cancellation. Those cases are separate. The class action is an allegation, not a finding. Amazon told Yahoo Shopping and other outlets that the Groundwork study unfairly cherry-picked its sample, and it has not conceded any of the claims.
Black Friday Fake Discount FAQ 2026
How Many Amazon Black Friday Deals Are Not Real Discounts?
Groundwork found 29.1% of 351 promoted deals were the same price or higher than the lowest in the prior 30 days. Amazon disputes the study.
How Many Deals Were More Expensive Than Before?
9.4% were priced higher than in the month before, rising to about 27% when looking back 90 days.
What Does Amazon Say About the Study?
Amazon says the study cherry-picked about 350 items from more than 10 million deals, and that 98% of products were at or below their prior 30-day price.
What Is the Difference Between a Real Deal and a Matched Price?
Groundwork counts a matched price as no savings. Amazon says matching the recent low is a legitimate deal.
How Can I Check if a Black Friday Deal Is Real?
Compare the sale price with the lowest price in the last 30 days on Keepa or CamelCamelCamel, not with the crossed-out price.
Are Fake Black Friday Discounts Illegal?
Federal guides require a “was” price to be genuine. Several states have specific rules. This report does not claim any retailer broke the law.
Do Prices Rise Before Black Friday?
Some do. KnownHost found 29% of 65 tech products rose before Black Friday 2024, averaging 20.5%.
Which Categories Have the Most Price Hikes?
KnownHost found tech accessories, then headphones, smartwatches and laptops. TVs and tablets saw the fewest hikes.
How Many Shoppers Plan to Use Black Friday Deals?
70%, up from 64% in 2025, according to Bain.
What Is the EU 30-Day Price Rule?
EU rules require a discount to reference the lowest price in the prior 30 days. It does not apply to US sales.
Are There Other Studies Besides Groundwork?
Yes. Visualping found 44.7% of Prime Day 2026 deals matched the month’s low and 42.8% cost more.
When Is Black Friday 2026?
Friday, November 27, 2026, the day after Thanksgiving. Cyber Monday is November 30.
Disclaimer: The data research report we present here is based on information found from various sources. We are not liable for any financial loss, errors, or damages of any kind that may result from the use of the information herein. We acknowledge that though we try to report accurately, we cannot verify the absolute facts of everything that has been represented.
